During Thorpe Thewles History Group’s (TTHG) research for the ‘David McLaren Diaries Project‘ reference was found to a disturbing court case concerning Samuel and Eliza Curry, of Town Farm in Thorpe Thewles, and Dora Johnson, a domestic servant in their employment.
By 1912 Samuel and Eliza Curry (34 and 29 years of age respectively) had taken over the running of Town Farm from Samuel’s mother Anne. Anne, then 64 years old, still lived with her son and daughter-in-law and their three young daughters.
In the first part of the twentieth century, it was still common for the daughters of working class families to earn their living and domestic service was considered an ideal occupation for young single women.
The working hours of domestic servants were long, often up to 17 hours each day, from 5.30 am in the morning until 10.30 pm. The work was endless and physically demanding and many employers still viewed their servants as dispensable creatures solely in existence for the comfort of their family. This appears to have been the case with Dora Johnson once she entered the Curry’s employment. Dora moved to Town Farm in June 1912 after answering an advertisement placed in a local newspaper.

The following account is Dora’s story after moving to Thorpe Thewles. Rather than to try and summarise it we have chosen to present it in the form of three consecutive un-edited newspaper reports as published in the Teesside Weekly Herald during November 1912. Text highlighted in bold has been added for clarification purposes. In addition, comments on Dora’s story are presented from appropriate entries in the diaries (1911, 1912 and 1913) of David McLaren which were rediscovered in 2010 and subsequently transcribed by TTHG. The diarist wrote his above journals between the ages of 14 and 17 while living in Manor Farm, Thorpe Thewles. Living opposite Town Farm it is expected that David must have known the Curry family well.


The first reference to the case of the Curry’s servant girl in the diaries of David McLaren appears in his entry for 10th November 1912. It simply states the following;
‘The whole village is immensely interested in the Curry’s servant girl case. They were all at their doors yesterday morning with tin cans etc to give her a good send off, but to their disappointment Mrs Curry had not to appear yesterday, and so did not go.”
It is clear from this entry that the case had stirred up a lot of emotional feelings amongst the villagers in Thorpe Thewles who appear from the diary entry to have sided in support of Dora Johnson. The diary entry was written the day after the newspaper report below was published.
The Teesside Weekly Herald – Saturday November 9th 1912
ASTOUNDING STORY OF CRUELTY
______________
TOLD AT STOCKTON BY A SERVANT GIRL
______________
CHARGES THORPE FARMER AND HIS WIFE
______________
SENSATION IN COURT
______________
BOTH DEFENDANTS COMMITTED FOR TRIAL
______________
A case in which serious allegations were made, and in which a great amount of public interest was evinced, was heard at a special sitting of the Stockton Bench on Tuesday before Messrs L.Ropner and J.A.Badcock, when a well-known Thorpe farmer [Town Farm] and his wife, Samuel and Eliza Curry, were charged with neglecting to provide necessary food and lodgings for a domestic servant named Dora Johnson, aged 19 years, the daughter of William Johnson, 13, Dale-street, St Helen’s, Auckland, and further with causing bodily harm to Dora Johnson. A large number of witnesses were present, including several from Bishop Auckland district. [Dora was the fourth of six surviving children of William, a coal miner, and Mary].
______________
REMARKABLE EVIDENCE
Dora Johnson, a delicate-looking girl, who was too weak to stand, and had to be accommodated with a seat, said, in reply to Mr Faber, that she went to Mr and Mrs Curry’s in answer to an advertisement in the “North-Eastern Daily Gazette” stating that the wanted a strong useful girl. This was about four months ago. Mrs Curry agreed by letter to give her 5s a week [£20 today], and when she got their Mrs Curry said she would get her anything she wanted in the form of clothing and stop it out of her wages. She had been there about six weeks when she gave her mistress notice that she intended to leave.
At first she slept in a comfortable bed room, and had plenty of good food. Witness was frightened of Mrs Curry, and after she gave her notice Mrs Curry began to thrash her and did so every day with a horsewhip (produced). Sometimes she got into the farmyard and dared not into the house, and when she did go in Mrs Curry would knock her down on to the floor and lash her with a whip all over her body. When witness was washing the floor she used to whip her all the time.
“A Lion-tamer”
Mr Faber: And what did she say she did it for? – She said she was a lion tamer. Proceeding, the girl said on one occasion Mrs Curry knocked her (witness’s) head against the wall, and said, “Work for the night is coming”. Sometimes she struck her with the stock of the whip, with a tin ladle, and with an iron rod. The only reason why Mrs Curry treated her in this way was that she could not-get on quick enough with her work. Witness left on Saturday, October 12th, and before she got away Mrs Curry gave her a good lashing.
On the Thursday just prior to her leaving, she was working in the wash-house when Mrs Curry came in, fastened her hands behind her back, laid her on the washing-table, lifted up her clothes, and beat her with a stick, which was like a stack stob [a pointed stick used in thatching hay stacks]. On one occasion she had cleaned the fire-side up, and was so weak when she was getting up that she had to support herself by putting her hand on the side of the fireplace. Which she smeared with her hand, on which there was blacklead. This Mrs Curry made her lick off with her tongue, and Mrs Curry stood over her until she did so. (Sensation in court).
On the day that she left at 6.30 at night she had no food, and when she asked for some she said she would rather give it to the dogs than to her. She had nothing to eat on the day previously. On the Wednesday before she left Mr and Mrs Curry went to Stockton market, and Mrs Curry told Mr Curry’s mother before she left that she must not give witness anything to eat until she (defendant) came back; and when Mrs Curry did return she would not give her anything to eat.
Mr Faber: That is to say, that you had nothing on the Wednesday, very little on the Thursday, nothing on the Friday, and nothing on the Saturday? – That is so. She was very ill at the time, and was too weak to do her work. When she did leave at 5.30 o’clock on the Saturday she felt very ill and told Mrs Curry so. She said, “Get yourself off”.
The Male Defendant
The male defendant drove her to Carlton station, carried her box to the platform, and she arrived home at West Auckland about 8.30 p.m.
The male defendant, proceeded witness, was sometimes present when his wife thrashed her, and he never tried to stop her. On one occasion when her mistress was lashing her with the horse whip Mr Curry came in and said, “It’s a good job I’ve found that whip, Liza; it has come in useful”. After the thrashing at that time she was so bad that she could not fasten her clothing. On one Monday morning Mr Curry called her at half-past five, and she was too weak to get up. Then she heard Mrs Curry coming, and she managed to get up. She was so frightened that she did something which made Mrs Curry angry, and she pushed her downstairs.
A day or so after that she was on her knees lighting the kitchen fire, and because it was not burning quick enough Mrs Curry pushed her head foremost into the fire. Her blouse caught fire and the male defendant, who was present, never attempted to give her any help in getting her blouse off. She was also burned in the face.
That day she was passing Mr Curry in the kitchen doorway, when, without saying anything at all, he struck her with his fist, and caused her ear to bleed.
After what witness accidentally did on the morning that Mrs Curry frightened her in her bed-room, she was compelled to sleep in a porch way downstairs between two doors, one of which opened into the kitchen and the other into the farmyard. The door leading into the house was locked by the male defendant. There was no bed in the porch, and all she had to sleep upon was a four legged stool (produced).
There were no bed clothes, and she had to cover herself up with her jacket (produced). It was very cold, and when she complained to the defendants, Mr Curry took no notice, and Mrs Curry merely said, “It does not matter”.
There was not sufficient room in the porch to enable her to lie down. It was a cement floor, and in consequence of the manner in which she was treated her legs began to swell.
Work in Scanty Attire
A week or so before she left Mrs Curry made her take off all her clothes, excepting her combinations, and go out and scrub some bricks in the yard. It was a very cold morning, and when she was doing this work in her scanty attire, the male defendant came up, but did not say anything.
When she first went to the farm there was a boy there named Norman, who ran away one morning because Mrs Curry threw some hot tea over him. She had been made to scrub floors dressed in no other garment excepting a chemise. About a fortnight before she left Mrs Curry put some water in a dirty bedroom utensil and made her drink it.
Sensation in Court
At this there was again sensation in Court, during which the female defendant screamed and fainted, but was soon revived.
After this, continued the witness, she tried to run away, but the male defendant caught her and gave her a good thrashing. When she wanted to write to her mother Mrs Curry always stood over her and made her write to her dictation. She was never allowed out of the house.
Mr Badcock (Magistrate): Not on a Sunday? – No.
Answering a further question by Mr Faber, witness said that on one occasion Mr Curry struck her on the face with a slipper, and Mrs Curry said, “That’s right, give her another crack, Sam”.
Cross-examined by Mr R.Cohen, who defended, witness said Mrs Curry had never given her notice to leave. It was not true that Mrs Curry frequently bought sweets for her, but she did not buy her a pennyworth on the morning that she left.
The examination and cross-examination of the girl lasted an hour and ten minutes.
Sarah Gladwell, of Tindale crescent, Bishop Auckland, stated that on October 12th she had met Dora Johnson on bar road from the railway station to her home. She told her that she had left her situation. She was then very weak; and was standing against a wall crying. She was scarcely able to walk.
Witness saw her a few weeks prior to her going to Thorpe, and had found her to be a strong healthy girl.
The Mother’s Evidence
Mary Johnson, mother of Dora, said that when her daughter went to Curry’s she was strong and healthy, and weighed over ten stone. After she had been there about a month she had a letter from her daughter. She was a good girl, and on three different occasions she sent money home.
When her daughter came home on October 12th, she and her husband were away for a week-end. They returned on Monday, and found their daughter in bed. She was crying out for bread and was very ill.
Neither she nor her husband could at first recognise that it was their daughter so great a change was there in her.
She was covered with marks and bruises and was so ill that she could not get any explanation from her that she could understand. On the first night witness had to stay up with her daughter. She was delirious, and crying out for bread, and pleading to someone not to lash her with a whip.
Inspector Heanly, stated that on his first visit to the house of the prosecutor, he saw the girl Dora in the presence of both parents. The girl was rambling in her mind, and seemed to be appealing to someone not to hit her with a whip.
She was very much emaciated, and had several bruises upon her body and the mark of a burn on her face.
Doctor’s Grave Testimony
Dr. Murdo Buchanan, Bishop Auckland, stated that on October 15th he examined the girl. He had known her for over five years. He would have estimated her weight at about 9 stone to 9½ stone before she went to serve at Thorpe. She weighed about 6½ stone when she returned.
When he first saw her on October 15th she was so emaciated that she looked like some one in an advanced state of consumption.
Witness proceeded to describe in detail the numerous bruises. She suffered from physical nervousness. There was no disease about the girl, and her condition, he was satisfied, was due to insufficient food and cruelty.
Cross-examined by Mr Cohen, witness said the weights he had given of the girl were only estimated.
Edith Mary May Rushforth (15) stated that her sister used to milk Curry’s cows, and she sometimes went with her. She was present one morning when Mrs Curry picked up a dirty saucepan and struck Dora Johnson across the head with it, and made her wash it several times.
There was a girl named Stamp staying with the Currys, and she told the girl to hit Dora with a stick across the back and on the toes. Dora had slippers on, but no stockings, and the girl did as she was instructed. She had also seen Mrs Curry strike Dora with a stick and make her cry.
She once heard Mrs Curry tell Dora to go and feed the hens with some cold potatoes, and saw Dora eat three or four of them.
Story of the Youth
Norman Victor Stoker 19, Derby-street, Thornaby, stated that he was in service with the defendants from April to August last. He was there when the girl Dora Johnson arrived. She was then very clean and healthy. He had seen Mrs Curry strike Dora four or five blows with a wet towel over the face.
Dora had complained to him about insufficient food and ill-treatment. After he had been at the farm some weeks he was compelled to take his meals out of the house, and when he complained of not getting plenty to eat they would not give him any more.
The girl rose regularly about 5:15 o’clock in the morning, and he had seen her scrubbing the floor of the milk-house at a quarter to twelve at night.
He left the farm because Mrs Curry struck him, and then Mr Curry hit him with his fist in the mouth.
By Mr Cohen: He had heard comment based on Dora’s thin condition, and she replied, “Last place I was at the missus got the meat and gave me the bones to look after”.
Ada Beadle and Rebecca Bainbridge, of Thorpe, spoke to the girl’s healthy condition when she arrived at Thorpe.
Johnston Beadle, a youth, said he had been in service with the defendants and had seen Mrs Curry strike Dora. Frank Dresser, Coxhoe, said he was in service with the defendants from July to September last. He had seen Mrs Curry put the girl into a horse trough head foremost and scrub her with a scrubbing brush. Dora was dirty at the time and required washing. He had also seen Mrs Curry strike her with a slipper and a ladle.
By Mr Cohen: She was an untidy and dirty girl.
Annie Elizabeth Rushforth said she did occasional work for the defendants, and once heard Mrs Curry threaten to smash a whip over Dora’s head.
Inspector Raisbeck stated that when he apprehended the defendants and charged them, they made no reply. Later, when witness was taking the whip away, they denied that they had a whip when the girl Johnson was with them.
Mr Cohen admitted that there was a prima facie case against the female defendant; which must be tried before a jury, but he submitted that there was no corroboration of the evidence against the male defendant, and he should be released.
The Defence Reserved
The Bench were satisfied that there was a prima facie case against both defendants, and, Mr Cohen reserving the defence, they were committed for trial at the Assizes [i.e. Crown Court], bail being allowed.
______________
The next newspaper report picks up the story after the case had been referred to the Assizes or Crown Court in Durham.
North-Eastern Daily Gazette – Thursday November 14th 1912
ASTOUNDING STORY
______________
Of Cruelty to Servant Girl Near Stockton
______________
FARMER & HIS WIFE
______________
CHARGES AT DURHAM ASSIZES TO-DAY.
______________
SHOCKING ALLEGATIONS
______________
In view of the serious and astounding allegations that had been made before the Stockton magistrates in the court below, considerable interest was taken in the trial at the Durham Assizes to-day, before Mr Justice Pickford, of a well-known South Durham farmer and his wife, who were charged with cruelty her blouse catching fire, to a domestic servant.
The accused was Samuel Curry (34), farmer, of Thorpe Thewles, and his wife, Eliza Ann Curry (30), and both were indicted on two charges, to which they pleaded not guilty.
The first charge was that being legally liable they unlawfully and wilfully refused to provide food and lodging for Dora Johnson, employed by them as domestic servant, between August 1st and October 12th last, and so endangered her life.
The second was by their conduct they had unlawfully and maliciously caused certain bodily harm to Johnson, and so endangered her life.
It was alleged that the girl Johnson had been thrashed with a whip, struck with a whip stock, a tin ladle, an iron rod, pushed into a fire, and compelled to work in scanty attire with insufficient food.
______________
CASE FOR THE PROSECUTION
Mr. Paley Scott, assisted by Mr Robson, prosecuted, and Mr Mitchell Innes, K.C., and Mr Mortimer (instructed by Mr Cohen, Stockton) defended.
In outlining the case, Mr Paley Scott, related a remarkable story. He stated that the girl, Dora Johnson, was about 19 years of age, and lived with her parents near Bishop Auckland.
About June their saw an advertisement in the “North-Eastern Daily Gazette,” inserted by Mrs Curry, for a servant, and they answered it. Upon some date in that month the girl went into prisoners’ service. At the time she was a healthy, jolly girl.
The evidence of her mother and the doctor, with regard to her condition when she came back from service, showed that she was a physical and nervous wreck.
Her life at that time was actually thought by the doctor to be in danger. She was ragged and emaciated, and, according to the evidence, this change in her condition was the direct result of the treatment she had received at the hands of the two prisoners during the five months she had been engaged with them.
When she first went into their employment everything went well, and she was properly fed, and had a bedroom and a bed to sleep in. She was, however, frightened of Mrs Curry, with the result that at the end of six weeks she gave a month’s notice, which Mrs Curry would not accept.
“Regular Habit of Flogging”
From that day there came a complete change in the treatment received from the female prisoner.
After that, apparently, Mrs Curry began to make a regular habit of flogging almost every day.
Mrs Curry used to hit her anywhere on the body while she was doing her work about the house. On many occasions when this happened Mr Curry was present and saw what took place without making any observation or attempting to stop his wife from doing it.
On one occasion, indeed, when the wife was flogging her in that way Mr Curry said, “It’s a good job, Eliza, I found that whip. It has come in very handy.”
The girl gave no provocation to Mrs Curry, who seemed to be a woman of violent temper.
Whether this treatment was entirely the result of that temper or not, he did not know, but it almost appeared that the female prisoner took a positive pleasure in inflicting pain and torture upon the girl, as while the girl was scrubbing the floor the woman would stand over her with a whip lashing her, and remarking something to the effect that she was a “lion tamer.
About the 13th September Johnson was particularly severely flogged, and she was hardly able to put her clothes on afterwards.
Continuing, Mr Paley Scott stated that Mrs Curry had apparently entered some arrangement with regard to providing her with clothes and deducting money from her wages to pay for them.
On September 20th, however, the girl was sent outside to scrub the bricks with which the yard was paved clad only in her combinations.
She was always made to work in the house in bare feet, never being allowed to wear boots and stockings when in the house.
Alleged Revolting Incident
About the same date a particularly unpleasant incident occurred. Mrs Curry brought down from the bedroom a chamberpot. From this she emptied the contents and put some water from the kitchen tap, and stood over the girl and made her drink it.
According to the girl’s story on the same day she was feeling very weak, and she felt some difficulty in rising when Mrs Curry called at 5.30. She then heard upon the stairs the footsteps of Mrs Curry. She got out of bed, but owing to her weak condition or some other reason something happened.
Mrs Curry took her by the hair and dragged her from the bedroom and flung her down along the steps, hurting her head badly.
From that date the girl was never allowed to go to sleep in a room in the house, but was put each night by Mr Curry into a porch. This was only five feet by five feet six inches, with a cement floor, which was too short for the girl to lie down upon. She was provided with a wooden stool upon which to spend the night, and had only the clothing she was wearing to protect her from the cold.
During that time the flogging with the whip continued regularly from day to day and the girl was kept at work from 5.30 in the morning until 10 o’clock at night without being allowed the opportunity of going out for a walk or to church.
On the 15th October, when Johnson was working in one of the upstairs rooms, something annoyed Mrs Curry, who took up the nearest object, which happened to be an iron bar, and struck the girl with it on the left wrist and arm causing severe bruises.
On the same date, the girl would tell them, Mr Curry had met her in the kitchen and struck her with a slipper.
Endeavour to Escape
On the same night the girl actually endeavoured to run away, but before she reached the gates of the farm she was seen by Mr Curry, who caught her and brought her back to the house by the neck, finally fastening her in the porch.
On October 8th a possibly more serious state of things arose. During this time, according to the girl’s evidence, she had only been provided very scantily with food, and on that date the only food she was given was a piece of bread and a drink of milk. On the following day, Mrs Curry, when she left for Stockton Market, told her mother-in-law, who remained behind in charge of the farm, not to give Johnson anything to eat till her return. These instructions were carried out.
On the 10th and 11th of October the girl had practically nothing to eat, and became so weak that she was simply unable to do her work and was informed by Mrs Curry that she must go home.
Thus, for about four days, he believed, the only food the girl had was a piece of bread and a drink of milk.
On October 12th, the last day Johnson spent in prisoner’s employment, the girl got up at 5.30 in the morning and lighted the fire. She experienced some difficulty in getting it to burn.
Mr Curry came in from the next room, and after watching her, went up behind her, and pushed her headfirst into the fire. The girl’s forehead was burnt, and her blouse was set on fire. Hearing her screams Mrs Curry rushed into the kitchen and pulled off her blouse.
About 8.30 on the same morning Mr Curry, as the girl was going about her work on the farm, without saying anything to her struck with his violently with his opened fist on the right ear, making it bleed.
At 5 o’clock in the evening Mr Curry told Johnson to “get off”. Mr Curry placed her box on the trap as she was too weak to carry it herself, and drove her to the station.
On her arrival at Bishop Auckland she was unable to walk alone, and was found at the side of the road by a neighbour who assisted her home.
Why Did She Not Complain?
It might be asked, remarked Mr Scoot, why the girl did not write and tell her mother the treatment she was receiving. Johnson would tell them that when she wrote home Mrs Curry stood over her, and dictated what she should write, and so she wrote it. The female prisoner also took the letter to the post herself.
It almost seemed incredible, added counsel, that the girl never made more than one unsuccessful attempt to run away.
He further pointed out that the girl was not as intelligent as girl’s of her age as many were. The treatment she had received suggested to him that the reason she had not attempted to escape from the farm was that she was reduced to a state of absolute serfdom, and was demoralised in body and nerve.
The question that also might be raised why the girl had not stolen food, but he would mention that the place in which the food was kept was always locked, and when Mr Curry went away the key was always left in charge of the female prisoner’s brother-in-law, who always remained behind.
______________
The last of our three newspaper articles covering this case deals with the court’s verdict and the sentencing of the accused.
North-Eastern Daily Gazette – Friday November 15th 1912
ASTOUNDING STORY
______________
Of Cruelty at Farm Near Stockton
______________
FARMER & HIS WIFE
______________
FOUND GUILTY OF CAUSING GRIEVOUS BODILY HARM
______________
TO SERVANT GIRL
______________
HEAVY SENTENCES
______________
The concluding stages of the trial of Samuel Curry (34), farmer, and his wife, Eliza Ann Curry (30) to place at the Durham Assizes to-day before Mr Justice Pickford.
The charges against the prisoners were that they had refused to provide food and lodgings to Dora Johnson, employed by them as a servant at their farm at Thorpe Thewles between August 1st and October 12th, and that they had caused her certain bodily harm.
Mr Paley Scott and Mr Robson prosecuted, and Mr Mitchell Innes, K.C., and Mr Mortimer (instructed by Mr Reuben Cohen, Stockton), appeared for the defence.
The evidence had been concluded the previous evening, and Mr Mitchell Innes having addressed the jury for the defence last night, Mr Paley Scott to-day made the concluding address for the prosecution, after which his lordship summed up.
The considerable interest in the case was maintained and there was a large attendance of the public in the Crown Court when the case was commenced.
The jury found both prisoners “Not guilty of neglect, but “Guilty” of grievous bodily harm.
______________
MR PALEY SCOTT’S SPEECH
Mr. Paley Scott said that it had been strongly and eloquently urged that it was possible for the girl’s story to be true, and suggested that it was equally impossible for the girl to have made up that story.
As for the defence, surely it was an almost too good a case that had been put before them by his learned friend. According to witnesses for the defence, not only was the girl in a quite healthy condition when she left the farm, but they said that she was better than when she came.
Old Mrs Curry clearly said that the girl was better, healthier, and stronger and more cheerful on the day she left. The male prisoner had stated that when he drove the girl away to the station she was singing hymns and songs. He thought that the jury could not accept that, and he ventured to suggest that they were putting the case too high.
Whatever the condition of the girl was on the Saturday she left the farm, on the Monday that her mother came home and saw her she was an emaciated wreck, and her body was covered in bruises. There was nothing in the account given by both the accused to account for that state of things.
If they accepted the story of the defendants they would have to believe that between Saturday and Monday something had happened to reduce the girl to the state in which she was found.
He ventured to think that the story of the girl and the evidence of Dr Buchanan made the defence incredible and unbelievable.
If the jury felt that they could not accept the girl’s story there was an end of the case, but if they could be would asked them to find defendants guilty.
As for the girl’s statement with regard to sleeping in the porch the defendant denied it absolutely. The girl, they said, had burnt herself by using paraffin oil to light the fire, and much had been made of the fact that the girl had not complained of her ill-treatment. The reason was, however, that the girl was in abject terror, and dared not.
THE JUDGE’S SUMMING UP
His Lordship, summing up, said, the case was not only a serious one, but also a difficult one, made none the less difficult from the fact that they might think the evidence on both sides was exaggerated, and that they could not wholly accept either side. It was not unusual to find that when people had a grievance, they exaggerated the grievance and also that when people had a defence that they mind find their story exaggerated too.
That, however, did not make the case any easier to deal with, and what they had to do was to get rid of the exaggeration on either side, and find out whether there was any evidence which satisfied them that the two defendants, or even one of them, had, in fact, treated the girl substantially in the way in which she said they had.
His Lordship proceeded to review the evidence at length, and speaking of the allegations to the girl being obliged to sleep in the porch, said that, if that was done at all it was a cruel thing. It seemed difficult to believe that it went on for so long as five weeks.
Speaking of the medical evidence, he said it seemed to corroborate the story that the bruises and injuries found on the girl were caused while she was in the defendant’s house.
The defendant, Samuel Curry, had said that the girl was singing hymns and songs as he drove her to the station, and it was this that led him to suggest that there might be exaggerations on both sides.
It seemed extraordinary to him that the girl was found within an hour unable to walk home, and in such a state that she had to be helped home.
It was extraordinarily difficult to reconcile Curry’s statement with the doctor’s evidence. The doctor was called in on Tuesday, and found the girl to be most extremely emaciated, and the doctor said she looked like one who was suffering from consumption.
The explanation offered by the Currys was that the bruises on her back had been caused by her having fallen down and so injuring her back, while the injury to her arm was caused by the wheel of the wringing machine.
It was for them to say whether the prosecution had made out a case of ill-treatment by one or both of the accused.
The cases of violence alleged against the man were fewer, and if they thought these were not proven, then they should not find him guilty, unless they thought he had encouraged his wife.
His Lordship asked the jury to answer two questions: Whether they found the defendants, or either of them had unlawfully withheld food and lodgings in such a way as to endanger life, or permanently injuring the health of the girl, and whether the defendants, or either of them, were guilty of inflicting grievous bodily harm to her.
THE VERDICT
The jury retired to consider their verdict, and after 35 minutes returned to the court, and, in reply to the Clerk, and they found the prisoners “Not guilty” of having withheld food and lodging so as to endanger the life or health of the girl, but they found the prisoners “Guilty” of having caused grievous bodily harm to her.
On hearing the verdict the female prisoner, who had been seated throughout the trial in a chair, and broke out into tears. She was attended to by the wardress. The male prisoner showed no emotion whatever.
His Lordship said he would defer sentence until after the adjournment for lunch.
THE SENTENCES
Samuel Curry was sentenced to twelve months’ imprisonment with hard labour, his wife to eighteen months.
______________
We leave the final comment on this story (for now at least) to David McLaren (from his diary entry of Friday 15th November 1912), without whose diaries we would never have known of this story in the first place.
“Mr & Mrs Curry have been tried by the Judge at the Durham Assizes yesterday and to-day, and were found guilty of inflicting bodily harm on their servant, Dora Johnson, by the jury. Sam Curry was sentenced to 12 month’s hard labour, while Eliza Curry got 18 months. Old Mrs Curry and the kids are still at Thorpe. Nobody seems to be on the side of Sam & Eliza, the general idea being that they ought to have got more.”
It is likely that both Samuel and Eliza Curry served out their sentences in Durham Gaol. A search of prison records has not yet been undertaken.
It is not known if the Curry’s ever returned to Thorpe after their release from prison. Research on this aspect of the story together with the post ordeal recovery of Dora Johnson’s is on-going.
It would be nice to think this disturbing incident in Thorpe Thewles’ history represented an isolated episode. However, preliminary investigations suggest that this may not be the case. It has been reported that there was at least one other young maid of this period, Florence Dale from Guisborough, ran away from service in the village after reported mal-treatment from her employers. This story is currently being investigated further.
Samuel and Eliza Curry are buried in St. James’ Churchyard, Thorpe Thewles along with other members of the Curry family.

Churchyard, Thorpe Thewles
Acknowledgement:
The above article is based on one similar by Paul Dunnill published in TTHG Newsletter No.7, May 2011.

