Tag: St. Mary the Virgin

  • Norton Church – Historic Graffiti Survey

    Norton Church – Historic Graffiti Survey

    Figure 1: The church of St. Mary the Virgin, Norton

    Between March 2023 and February 2024 Thorpe Thewles History Group (TTHG) took part in the church graffiti recording surveys initiated across County Durham and Northumberland as part of the ‘Belief in the North East Project‘ (BitNE). This was a community archaeology project led by staff from Durham University. For additional background information on the subject of historic church graffiti, its common forms, categorisation and interpretation, reference should be made to the appropriate Project Introduction Page which can be found elsewhere within this website.

    The Grade I listed church of St. Mary the Virgin, Norton is of an early medieval foundation. The church contains elements of Anglo-Saxon through to modern fabric as illustrated in the survey report below. An outline of the surviving architectural features of this historic monument can be found on in its official Historic England listing.

    TTHG’s graffiti survey included detailed examinations of both the church’s interior and exterior walls to an approximate height of 3 m above ground level. Above this the accuracy of the survey was far more limited due to visibility restrictions.

    A summary sheet along with a descriptive listing and set of associated illustrations of the graffiti recorded during TTHG’s survey of Norton church is contained in the file linked below.

    Note on Survey Recording Images

    High resolution images are available for each graffiti item illustrated in the above linked survey report by request from TTHG directly. When requesting copies of these images please cross reference their individually stated file names as given in the recording sheet.

    Discussion of Survey Results

    Significant re-building and alterations made to the outer walls of the nave at Norton church has likely resulted in the loss of significants amounts of earlier historic graffiti. Despite this a limited yet varied array of historic graffiti types were recorded during this survey. Some of the most interesting recorded examples are summarised below.

    • Various sets of conjoined ‘VV’ marks on an internal window ledge within the southwest end of the chancel.
    • Various sets of incised hole and cup marks on an internal window ledge within the southwest end of the chancel.
    • Two groups of heavily worn groove marks. One located in the outer door arch mouldings of the church’s south porch and the other on the internal side of the chancel’s south door.
    • A segmented cross within a compass drawn circle on a column in the arcade of the north aisle.
    • An adjoining pair of mass dials on the outer wall of south buttress of east end wall of the chancel.
    • A set of inscribed initials and associated geometric designs on an internal window ledge within the southwest end of the chancel.

    The above are discussed further below.

    Conjoined ‘VV’ Marks

    Four sets of conjoined ‘VV’ marks (half of which are inverted) were recorded on an internal window ledge within the southwest end of the chancel with additional, smaller and less clear ones, also noted in the same location. In some cases the conjoined ‘VV’ marks were inverted.

    (Click on the images shown in the reel above to see a larger view)

    The conjoined double ‘V’ symbol is probably one of the commonest yet most enigmatic marks in the pantheon of historic graffiti marks known from the UK. The symbol is often referred to as ‘Maria’ or ‘Marian’ marks and can often be found inverted to resemble a capital ‘M’, or even shown on their side. The symbol has been interpreted as being associated with the cult of the Virgin Mary, and it has been suggested that the ‘conjoined double ‘V’ represents the initial letters of the term ‘Virgo Virginum’ (Virgin of Virgins). However, more recent research suggests this interpretation unlikely.

    The possible connection between the ‘VV’ symbol and the Latin prayer or phrase ‘Virgo Virginum’ was first mooted in 1990, with particular reference to the examples of the motif that were recorded on medieval pilgrim ‘badge’ type souvenirs.  The term ‘Virgo Virginum’ is the first line of the sung prayer ‘O Virgo Virginum’, one of the ‘O Antiphons’ which were chanted at vespers in the days leading up to the feast of the Nativity. In the traditional European catholic church there were seven of these Antiphons, each representing a name and virtue of Christ, with the English church adding the 8th , that of ‘O Virgo Virginum’, in the later Middle Ages. However, even during this time it is believed that this phrase wasn’t well known in England, being limited to only the larger religious institutions. The fact that the phrase was largely confined to England also makes the popularity of the symbol as graffiti found in mainland European churches difficult to explain. This symbol is also one of the few ritual protection marks that made the occasional cross-over into more traditional church art form, appearing above the west door of Fakenham church, in Norfolk, where it is associated with the Virgin Mary, and on the 15th century font at Aylsham church, where it is associated with the scourging of Christ. The symbol is also know to appear on several designs of medieval lead ampule found in England as well as graffiti forms found in several post medieval historic buildings.

    It is possible that the origins of this symbol may be far earlier than the Middle Ages. The earliest examples of it being used for ritual purposes are to be found in the runic writing systems of Scandinavia, and even today it is still regarded as a Holy sign associated with life, death and fertility in many areas of the eastern Baltic.

    It is noted that Norton church is dedicated to St. Mary the Virgin which may make the presence of such marks more poignant.

    Incised Holes and Cup Marks

    Various incised hole marks on an internal window ledge within the southwest end of the chancel. The best example of these comprises a set of nine bored holes arranged in a three by three rectangular matrix.

    (Click on the images shown in the reel above to see a larger view)

    Such marks are a common find in many churches, both those with and without graffiti inscriptions, are dot patterns comprising multiple incised or worn holes, i.e. ‘dot’ or ‘cup’ marks. In some cases the ‘dots’ are clearly just being used as the terminus points for other inscriptions, such as crosses or stars, but in others their function is far less obvious. A lot of these ‘dot’ patterns have been deeply inscribed into the surface of the stone or plaster, and they do tend to be found in groups which are often arranged in geometric patterns. 

    In a number of recorded cases across England the holes appear to be created in numerical sets, with the number of ‘dots’ per set being generally of an uneven number and commonly in groups of three, five, seven and nine. Certain uneven numbers had considerable significance in the medieval church, such as the Trinity and the seven sacraments, and numbers were also regarded as powerful within aspects of medieval magic.

    It has been suggested that the holes or ‘dots’ are the result of local and regional practice of folk medicine. In some areas, particularly in France and Spain, it was until recently believed that the stone or plaster from a church, when ground to a fine powder and mixed with wine, was an effective cure for many illnesses and diseases. This may well have been the case in England also, although there is no direct evidence to support this idea. Indeed, the significance of these dot patterns may contain elements of any or all of the above.

    Worn Groove Marks

    Two sets of heavily worn groove marks were recorded as part of this survey. One located in the outer door arch moulding in the church’s south porch and the other on the internal side of the chancel’s south door. The latter comprises a very broad and deep horizontal groove which is overlaid with sets of much thinner vertical and diagonally arranged grooves arranged in parallel lines.

    (Click on the images shown in the reel above to see a larger view)

    Examples of heavily worn groove marks can be found in the fabric of many medieval British churches. These appear both inside and outside of the churches and are commonly found around window sills and door jambs. They are often encountered as sets of two or three vertical lines arranged in parallel to each other.

    Tradition ascribes such marks as being made by archers, sharpening their arrows before archery practice or by men at arms sharpening the edges of their steel weapons ahead of combat. However, in recent years, several strong arguments have been proposed to challenge this explanation of how such grooves have been made. Rather than being the results of purely practical edge sharpening exercises, it is now suggested (at least in part) that they are the results of a more ritual practice whereby arrows and/or blades have been rubbed against the consecrated church fabric so as to convey good luck and protection on both them and their owners. 

    Segmented Cross within a Compass Drawn Circle

    A compass drawn cross design was recorded on the inner side of a column in the arcade of the north aisle. It comprised four equal sectors, in the form of a cross alisée, arranged within a compass drawn circular border. TTHG are of the opinion that this design may represent a consecration cross, or at least the setting out lines of one.

    Consecration crosses were once a common sight on both the interior and exterior walls of English churches . However, today they are encountered as rare survivals and often only exist as faintly inscribed outlines in church stonework.

    From a preliminary review of the results from the church graffiti surveys carried out as part of the wider ‘BitNE’ project, it would appear that survivals of consecration crosses are non common in northeast England. A possible one at Grindon, being an example on an exterior church wall, makes it rarer still. While other simpler designs of externally made crosses were recorded in the ‘BitNE’ church graffiti survey they were not typical of the well documented consecration crosses known from East Anglia (see Figure 2).

    Figure 2: A selection of painted consecration crosses from churches in Norfolk (Courtesy: Norfolk Medieval Graffiti Project)

    When originally created it is believed that most consecration crosses would have been painted, typically using a red pigment. However, in most churches where they survive, the pigment has now been lost, leaving only the setting-out lines of the crosses around the walls. 

    Consecration cross designs were typically made with compasses or dividers in the form of a simple cross, leading to them often being mistaken for other types of similarly created apotropaic marks. They were sometimes created in very elaborate styles with foliated and engrailed borders. Generally consecration crosses tend to be much larger than the other compass drawn types of church graffiti designs, however, their size varies considerably.

    When a church was first constructed, or significantly altered, it had to be consecrated by the local Bishop prior to worship taking place in it. In essence, the structure had to be made into a sacred space. To do this the Bishop would bless the building and anoint it with holy oil, twelve times outside and twelve times inside. Each of the places that were anointed with oil would then be marked with a cross (i.e. a ‘consecration cross’). A late medieval woodcut representation of such a ceremony can be seen in the bottom right of Figure 3

    Figure 3: A late medieval woodcut illustration of a bishop blessing a consecration cross (c.1520 AD)

    For further information about church consecration crosses see the video presentation below.

    Mass Dials

    An interesting feature at Norton church is an adjoining pair of mass dials on the outer wall of the south buttress of east end wall of the chancel. The westerly of the two still has the remains of the basal section of the original iron gnomon at its centre. At the time of their discovery by TTHG these dials were unknown to the British Sundial Society.

    (Click on the images shown in the reel above to see a larger view)

     Mass dials, also known as scratch dials, have long been the subject of academic and antiquarian study. Indeed, it is a rarity to open a county archaeological journal from the 1920s or 1930s that does not contain some reference to them and over 6,000 have so far been documented across the country. In the current survey only mass dials comprising of incised or ‘scratched’ design were recorded.

    The traditional interpretation is that these simple sundials were used by either the parish priest, congregation or bell ringers, to calculate the correct time for services. A removable gnomon was located in each dial’s central whole with its shadow being cast onto its outer arrangement of radial marks (i.e. where each of which indicated a given time of day).

    Mass dials are most usually located on the south side of a church and can be found in many forms, shapes and sizes. If found elsewhere on a church then the traditional interpretation is that the stone into which they were carved has been moved or recycled. However, these traditional interpretations of non-south facing dials are now seen as being open to question. The number of these dials being recorded on the north side of churches, where they simply wouldn’t work due to the lack of direct sun light, is notable and the likelihood of them all being on recycled stone is slim. Many churches also have multiple and identical mass dials (e.g. Hales, in Norfolk which has eight). In other cases some mass dials are known to be located inside church porches, suggesting that there is much more to these simple dials than first meets the eye.

    Inscribed Initials and Geometric Designs

    As part of complex overlying arrangements of later medieval graffiti recorded on an internal window ledge within the southwest end of the chancel at Norton church are a set of inscribed initials and geometric designs. In some cases the initials are made within the geometric designs which take the outline form of a simple building frame. Many similar sets of markings have been recorded from historic graffiti surveys across the country. Many of these also bear what appear to be dates. Many of them are thought to be simple memorial markers to individuals.

    (Click on the images shown in the reel above to see a larger view)