Between March 2023 and February 2024 Thorpe Thewles History Group (TTHG) took part in the church graffiti surveys initiated across County Durham and Northumberland as part of the ‘Belief in the North East Project‘ (BitNE). This was a community archaeology project led by staff from Durham University. The project enabled local volunteers to work with professional archaeologists to study aspects of the fascinating archaeology of religion across northeast England. For additional information about the scope and aims of this wide ranging project, and in particular the northeast church graffiti survey aspects of it, click on the webpage and video links below.
The definition of ‘graffiti’ used as the basis for this project included any symbols, patterns and markings created by cutting, painting, drawing or burning into either the interior or exterior fabric of the church. Officially created interior church wall paintings were excluded from the project’s definition of ‘graffiti’.
The bulk of graffiti recorded was of an informal nature and could be categorised as textual, memorial or apotropaic in nature. However, additional formally made markings were also recorded. These include official markings made as part of, or in association with, a church’s construction, consecration or later use.
Project Inputs & Learnings
When considering historic graffiti it should be noted that its creation on building fabric was generally accepted by all until the mid-19th century when changing Victorians attitudes rejected it and its creation as being of an unsightly and vandalistic nature. While this attitude is that which persists to the present day it should be remembered that it wasn’t that of our pre-Victorian ancestors.
Figure 1: Locations of the churches selected by TTHG for their graffiti surveys as part of Durham University’s ‘Belief in the North East’ (BitNE) Project
As part of this project TTHG elected to survey a total of eight parishes distributed across southeast County Durham. Amongst these were two in the group’s home parish of Grindon along with others in adjacent and nearby parishes (see Figure 1). All of the churches surveyed were of medieval or early medieval foundation excepting for that at Thorpe Thewles which was late Victorian. It should be noted that most of the medieval churches surveyed exhibited significant renovations, alterations and additions which principally dated from the 19th century. These typically included the removal or re-application of painted wall plaster, the re-dressing of some interior non-plastered stone walls plus general elements of enlargement and rebuilding. Such alterations have very likely obliterated significant amounts of earlier graffiti which may have been present on the interior walls of these churches. This has to be considered when drawing conclusions from the project’s findings or in the generation of any statistical analyses from its overall results.
This project proved to be very rewarding for the TTHG members who took part in it, as noted below.
It provided an excellent introduction into the relatively recent and fascinating subject of studying church graffiti over the ages, from the medieval through to the modern period.
It allowed the development a solid understanding of the different types of graffiti commonly found in British churches along with methodologies relating to graffiti investigation, interpretation and recording techniques.
It allowed the group to make original and positive contributions to the on-going historic research and recording of the churches surveyed. While several of the churches included in the survey have already had their histories, architecture and funerary monuments extensively examined and published (most notably Norton and Hart), none of them have ever previously had their historic graffiti reported on or officially recorded.
A wide range of graffiti, dating from the medieval to 20th century, was recorded across TTHG’s surveys. Most of the graffiti recorded was located internally within the churches surveyed, with far less being recorded on external walls. Due to insurance, along with health and safety related issues, it was not possible for TTHG to access above the ground or first floors of most of the churches that had accessible bell towers. Similarly visibility limitations meant that it was very difficult to accurately survey interior and exterior church walls much above 2.5m above ground level.
Each church graffiti survey was conducted by at least five TTHG members, typically over an initial two to four hours period with shorter second, and sometimes third, visits to each church being conducted to further re-photograph and measure some of the items of graffiti discovered.
Types & Interpretation of some of the commoner forms of Church Graffiti
Each example of graffiti recorded was allocated by type into one of the nationally recognised and defined categories of church graffiti as indicated in the table shown in Figure 2 below. Many of these categories were first established during the ground breaking Norfolk Medieval Graffiti Survey (NMGS) which was established in 2010 as a volunteer led community archaeology project.
Figure 2: Summary of graffiti types and forms recorded by TTHG’s survey by church location in southeast County Durham
As indicated in Figure 2, several of the nationally recognised forms of church graffiti were particularly prevalent across the eight churches surveyed by TTHG. Several of these common types fall into the category of ‘ritual protection’ or ‘apotropaic marks‘, i.e. symbols believed to have the power to avert evil or harmful spirits. Such symbols are often found as graffiti in many historic buildings in locations considered vulnerable to the entrance of supernatural threats or spirits. These locations typically include doorways, windows, fireplaces and stairways. Apotropaic symbols can take various forms, such as geometric shapes, patterns and letters (for typical examples see Figure 1 above). Such graffiti typically dates from the medieval to ‘early modern’ periods but examples made as late as the 19th century are also known.
Several of the most common forms of church graffiti encountered during TTHG’s surveys are outlined (with interpretations, and illustrated examples taken from the surveys) in the expandable information sections below.
CrossMarks
Click on (+) For Information
These fall into two separate groups, namely consecration and simple inscribed cross marks. Each of these had separate functions and meanings to those who made them during the medieval period and are further discussed below.
Consecration Cross Marks – These were a once common sight on both the interior and exterior walls of English churches. However, today they are encountered as rare survivals and often only exist as faintly inscribed outlines in church stonework.
When a church was first constructed, or significantly altered, it had to be consecrated by the local Bishop prior to worship taking place in it. In essence, the structure had to be made into a sacred space. To do this the Bishop would bless the building and anoint it with holy oil, twelve times outside and twelve times inside. Each of the places that were anointed with oil would then be marked with a cross (i.e. a ‘consecration cross’). A late medieval woodcut representation of such a ceremony can be seen in the bottom right of Figure 2.
When originally created it is believed that most consecration crosses would have been painted, typically using a red pigment. However, in most churches where they survive, the pigment has now been lost, leaving only the setting-out lines of the crosses around the walls.
Consecration cross designs were typically made with compasses or dividers in the form of a simple cross, leading to them often being mistaken for other types of similarly created apotropaic marks. They were sometimes created in very elaborate styles with foliated and engrailed borders. Generally consecration crosses tend to be much larger than the other compass drawn types of church graffiti designs, however, their size varies considerably. For examples of known consecration cross designs, from a selection of mainly East Anglian churches, see the coloured illustration in the bottom right of Figure 2.
Simple Inscribed Cross Marks – Whilst it is hardly surprising to find crosses inscribed into churches what is remarkable are the typical locations where they are found. Generally, where recorded in England, the vast majority of inscribed crosses are found in church entrance doorways or their associated porches. These can vary from elaborate and deeply incised crosses to mere scratches on wall surfaces.
Traditionally these crosses are thought to have been created by people setting off on pilgrimage, or as thanksgiving for a safe return. However, there is no evidence for such an interpretation. It appears far more likely that where they appear in church porches their chosen locations are more related to the former use of this part of the church during the middle ages. Today, a church porch is often little more than a place to hang a church notice board. This was not the case in earlier times when they took on a more important function, with a number of ceremonies, such marriage and the ‘churching of women’, partly taking place there. In earlier times the porch also functioned as a parish office, where agreements and contracts were drawn up and witnessed. It is possible that some of the graffiti crosses found are related to transactions or agreements that were carried out in the porch, and were made as a result of such.
Simple inscribed crosses were one of the most common forms of graffiti encountered by TTHG across the eight churches surveyed.The crosses recorded took several forms from small simple designs to much larger and more ornate forms as indicated in Figure 3.
All of the cross forms recorded as part of TTHG surveys (where they were not obviously examples of mason’s marks) are assumed to have been made as devotional, good luck or ritual protection marks. However, it is questioned by TTHG if some of the larger and more ornate forms (such as examples found at Norton and Grindon. See Figure 3) are not examples of consecration crosses. While their forms may not be typical of consecration crosses recorded in several other well surveyed areas of England, they could possibly represent hitherto unrecognised northern English styles of such dedicatory devices.
Figure 3: A selection of cross form graffiti items recorded by TTHG as part of the BitNE Project
Conjoined ‘VV’ Marks
Click on (+) For Information
Although probably one of the more common forms of inscribed graffiti to be found on timber, stone, tombs and lead-work from churches, the conjoined double ‘V’ symbol is probably one of the most enigmatic. The symbol is often referred to as ‘Maria’ or ‘Marian’ marks and can often be found inverted to resemble a capital ‘M’, or even shown on their side. They are one of the commonest forms of church graffiti to be found in English churches and are often present in considerable numbers. The symbol has been interpreted as being associated with the cult of the Virgin Mary, and it has been suggested that the ‘conjoined double ‘V’ represents the initial letters of the term ‘Virgo Virginum’ (Virgin of Virgins). However, more recent research suggests this interpretation unlikely.
The possible connection between the ‘VV’ symbol and the Latin prayer or phrase ‘Virgo Virginum’ was first mooted by Brian Spencer in 1990, with particular reference to the examples of the motif he was recording on medieval pilgrim ‘badge’ type souvenirs. The term ‘Virgo Virginum’ is the first line of the sung prayer ‘O Virgo Virginum’, one of the ‘O Antiphons’ which were chanted at vespers in the days leading up to the feast of the Nativity. In the traditional European catholic church there were seven of these Antiphons, each representing a name and virtue of Christ, with the English church adding the 8th , that of ‘O Virgo Virginum’, in the later Middle Ages. However, even during this time it is believed that this phrase wasn’t well known in England, being limited to only the larger religious institutions. The fact that the phrase was largely confined to England also makes the popularity of the symbol as graffiti found in mainland European churches difficult to explain. This symbol is also one of the few ritual protection marks that made the occasional cross-over into more traditional church art form, appearing above the west door of Fakenham church, in Norfolk, where it is associated with the Virgin Mary, and on the 15th century font at Aylsham church, where it is associated with the scourging of Christ. The symbol is also know to appear on several designs of medieval lead ampule found in England as well as graffiti forms found in several post medieval historic buildings.
It is possible that the origins of this symbol may be far earlier than the Middle Ages. The earliest examples of it being used for ritual purposes are to be found in the runic writing systems of Scandinavia, and even today it is still regarded as a Holy sign associated with life, death and fertility in many areas of the eastern Baltic.
Only two churches in those surveyed by TTHG as part of this project were found to contain conjoined ‘VV’ marks’, these were Hart and Norton (see Figure 4). In the latter several examples were found in one particular location within the channel of the church. It is noted that Norton church is dedicated to St. Mary the Virgin which may make the presence of such marks more poignant.
Figure 4: Examples of two sets of conjoined ‘VV” marks from the south facing window ledge at the west end of the channel (behind the choir stalls) in Norton church
Worn Groove Marks
Click on (+) For Information
Examples of heavily worn groove marks can be found in the fabric of many medieval British churches. These appear both inside and outside of the churches and are commonly found around window sills and door jambs. They are most commonly encountered as sets of 2 or 3 vertical lines arranged in parallel to each other.
Tradition ascribes such marks as being made by archers, sharpening their arrows before archery practice or by men at arms sharpening the edges of their steel weapons ahead of combat. However, in recent years, several strong arguments have been proposed to challenge this explanation of how such grooves have been made. Rather than being the results of purely practical edge sharpening exercises, it is now suggested (at least in part) that they are the results of a more ritual practice whereby arrows and/or blades have been rubbed against the consecrated church fabric so as to convey good luck and protection on both them and their owners.
TTHG recorded several sets of worn groove markings as part of their survey of eight southeast County Durham churches. Some of the most notable of these examples were found at the churches at Norton, Billingham and Hart (see Figure 5).
Figure 5: A selection of ‘worn groove’ marks recorded by TTHG as part of the BitNE Project
Mass Dials
Click on (+) For Information
Mass dials, also known as scratch dials, have long been the subject of academic and antiquarian study, being amongst one of the first forms of inscribed church devices to be systematically recorded. Indeed, it is a rarity to open a county archaeological journal from the 1920s or 1930s that does not contain some reference to them and over 6,000 have so far been documented across the country. In the current survey only mass dials comprising of incised or ‘scratched’ design were recorded.
The traditional interpretation is that these simple sundials were used by either the parish priest, congregation or bell ringers, to calculate the correct time for services. A removable gnomon was located in each dial’s central whole with its shadow being cast onto its outer arrangement of radial marks (i.e. where each of which indicated a given time of day).
Mass dials are most usually located on the south side of a church and can be found in many forms, shapes and sizes. If found elsewhere on a church then the traditional interpretation is that the stone into which they were carved has been moved or recycled. However, these traditional interpretations of non-south facing dials are now seen as being open to question. The number of these dials being recorded on the north side of churches, where they simply wouldn’t work due to the lack of direct sun light, is notable and the likelihood of them all being on recycled stone is slim. Many churches also have multiple and identical mass dials (e.g. Hales, in Norfolk which has 8). In other cases some mass dials are known to be located inside church porches, suggesting that there is much more to these simple dials than first meets the eye.
As part of the eight southeast County Durham churches surveyed by TTHG undoubtedly the most interesting example of incised mass dials was at Norton church. Here two separate mass dials (one with parts of its central iron gnomon still in situ) were discovered immediately adjacent to each other on the outer southeast side of the church’s nave (see Figure 6).
Examples of sculptured early medieval sun dials (bearing designs carved in relief) plus post 17th century sun dials (often having ornate fixed iron/steel nomens) encountered during TTHG surveys were noted but not recorded as being part of what is conventionally part of a typical church graffiti survey.
Figure 6: Examples of two adjacent mass dials located on the outer southeast section of the chancel wall of Norton church
Compass Drawn Circles
Click on (+) For Information
This group of compass drawn designs are by far the most common single motif encountered in medieval church graffiti surveys in England with several thousand recorded to date. Their designs can take one of several forms as can be seen from the array shown in the top right hand side insert of Figure 1 above. They can range from simple circles, through six petalled flower designs (known as Daisy Wheels or Hexfoils), to highly complex geometric constructions. Whilst the majority of them are small in size, being less than 100mm across, larger examples have been recorded that are nearly a metre across. It was originally believed that these designs were created by the actual masons who built the churches. They were thought to be either the mason’s teaching their apprentices the basics of geometry or creating a guide for themselves to ensure that their own dividers were correctly adjusted.
Whilst some of the compass drawn designs were undoubtedly created by the medieval masons it now appears unlikely that they were responsible for anything other than a very small percentage. The sheer number of examples, inscribed into stonework, woodwork and even the lead linings of fonts, suggest that these designs were created by far more than a single trade group and that they had a clear and distinct meaning and function. At the present time it is generally believed that the vast majority of these designs acted as ‘ritual protection’ (i.e. apotropaic) markings. There is no simple explanation of the form and function of apotropaic markings. At their most basic level they could be seen as bringing luck and protecting individuals from evil or malign influence. At a more complex quasi-theological level it is considered that they were designed to trap the demons that roamed the world within their complex structure, quite literally pinning them to the walls.
Despite such markings being commonly recorded as part of other English county church graffiti surveys only one example was recorded by TTHG from the eight churches they surveyed in southeast County Durham. This was discovered on the outer east side of the south doorway porch of Hart church, see Figure 7.
Figure 7: Images the compass drawn apotropaic mark on the east part of the outer facing wall of the south doorway porch of Hart church
IncisedHole & Cup Marks
Click on (+) For Information
A common find in many churches, both those with and without graffiti inscriptions, are dot patterns comprising multiple incised or worn holes, i.e. ‘dot’ or ‘cup’ marks. In some cases the ‘dots’ are clearly just being used as the terminus points for other inscriptions, such as crosses or stars, but in others their function is far less obvious. A lot of these ‘dot’ patterns have been deeply inscribed into the surface of the stone or plaster, and they do tend to be found in groups which are often arranged in geometric patterns.
In a number of recorded cases across England the ‘dots’ appear to be created in numerical sets, with the number of ‘dots’ per set being generally of an uneven number and commonly in groups of three, five, seven and nine. Certain uneven numbers had considerable significance in the medieval church, such as the Trinity and the seven sacraments, and numbers were also regarded as powerful within aspects of medieval magic.
It has been suggested that the holes or ‘dots’ are the result of local and regional practice of folk medicine. In some areas, particularly in France and Spain, it was until recently believed that the stone or plaster from a church, when ground to a fine powder and mixed with wine, was an effective cure for many illnesses and diseases. This may well have been the case in England also, although there is no direct evidence to support this idea. Indeed, the significance of these dot patterns may contain elements of any or all of the above.
The best example of this type of graffiti recorded by TTHG as part of their survey of eight southeast County Durham churches was at Norton church and is shown in Figure 8.
Figure 8: An rectangular grid arrangement of nine incised holes from the south facing window ledge at the west end of the channcel (behind the choir stalls) in Norton church
Textual & Memorial Inscriptions
Click on (+) For Information
At many heritage sites, from cathedrals to castles, one of the most obvious types of graffiti encountered are those created by earlier visitors to the site and which comprise of personal names or initials sometimes which are accompanied by a date. What stands out is just how many of these textual inscriptions date to the 18th and 19th centuries and which are very neatly and precisely cut. At many historic churches and sites such graffiti is dismissed as the work of choirboys, or ‘naughty schoolboys’. However, in most cases, this simply couldn’t be further from the truth.
Until very recent times the creation of graffiti on ancient buildings wasn’t regarded as vandalism, or something that was even frowned upon. Graffiti was created by all levels of society, wishing to leave a mark of their visit, and many of our most notable ancient monuments, from the royal thrones in Westminster Abbey, to the Pyramids in Egypt, are literally covered in graffiti inscriptions. It is also clear, where research has been undertaken, that the people who made these inscriptions were often of relatively high social status and individuals who had the time and leisure to make such visits.
Whilst some people may frown at the way these inscriptions deface many ancient sites, it must be remembered that they too are telling a story; the story of how these sites first became tourist attractions and where individuals chose to memorialise their names for posterity.
One of the most concentrated areas of such graffiti recorded by TTHG, during their survey of southeast County Durham churches, was on a 15th century alabaster box tomb effigy in Redmarshall church. This single ‘soft’ stone medieval monument was covered in literally hundreds of carved names, personal initials and dates most of which were deemed by TTHG to date from the late 17th to mid-19th centuries (see Figure 9). Through subsequent research, TTHG were able to identify several of the individuals whose names appeared in the graffiti of this monument, ascertaining where and when they lived, their trades or professions and their links (where evident) to Redmarshall church.
Figure 9: A selection of the hundreds of names, initials and dates cut into the 15th century alabaster box tomb effigy of Sir Thomas de Langton and his wife at the east end of the south aisle of Redmarshall church
Masons’ & Carpenters’ Marks
Click on (+) For Information
Masons’ Marks – These functional marks were inscribed by stone masons on the dressed blocks used in the construction of churches (and other buildings). It is believed that they were used to help indicate and record which mason had prepared and dressed individual stones. As such they allowed a mechanism for identifying a mason’s output (and hence pay) and a way of keeping check on the quality of his work. An individual church may contain many different mason’s marks or many copies of the same symbol. Mason’s marks tend to be simple in their design, usually neatly executed and comprising a series of straight lines. This gave them the advantage of being produced with the minimum of effort whilst still being distinctive.
Mason’s marks are typically found throughout a church. However, unlike general graffiti markings, they also tend to appear higher up on the stonework, in areas that could only be reached with the aid of scaffolding or a ladder. What isn’t currently clear is whether mason’s continued with the same markings throughout their careers. Did their apprentices develop a variation on the theme of their master’s mark, or did they develop an entirely new symbol? Were mason’s marks passed from generation to generation? The fundamental problem with interpretation of mason’s marks is whether the same symbol appearing in two different churches was actually created by the same individual mason? Although not technically graffiti these marks were included as part of the current survey, as is typically the case in most other published English County church graffiti surveys. Sometimes it can be difficult to distinguish if some marks (for example simple crosses or saltires etc.) are mason’s marks or simple apotropaic symbols.
Carpenters’ Marks – These functional marks typically take the form of Roman numerals, that have been cut into the component parts of timber frameworks and fabrications to help indicate how the entire ensemble should be pieced together. They were typically made using a straight line often gouged into the surface of the wood using a race knife. Such marks were made on individual components within many timber framed buildings in which adjacent interconnecting timbers would be tagged with similar numbered marks to indicate their jointing. While their form was typically based on classical Roman numerals, the number four is usually represented as ‘IIII’, rather than ‘IV’. The convention for representing four as ‘IV’ and nine as ‘IX’ only emerged as the 16th century progressed, and took a considerable time to be universally adopted.
Surprisingly few mason’s marks were recorded by TTHG during their surveys of the eight southeast County Durham churches listed above. Where they were discovered they were often as only solitary examples, which again appeared surprising to TTHG. The survey of the ruins of Grindon church indicated three similar poorly executed cross shaped mason’s marks within its late 12th century nave (see Figure 10). Notable examples of carpenter’s marks were recorded by TTHG in the roof beams of Bishopton church and within several of the pews (of date c.1700) at Redmarshall church. Examples from these two locations are shown in Figure 10.
Figure 10: A selection of masons’ and carpenters’ marks recorded by TTHG as part of the BitNE Project
Ordnance Survey Bench Marks
Click on (+) For Information
An Ordnance Survey Bench Mark (OS BM) is a visible symbol which has been cut into rock or a similar durable material (such as a stone building or bridge) which, in conjunction with an Ordnance Survey (OS) map, enables the location’s height above mean sea-level to be determined. The benchmark comprises a symbol known as a ‘broad arrow’ surmounted by a horizontal bar. The precise elevation level measured by the benchmark is that where the level of the ‘bar’ joins that of the pointed tip of the ‘board arrow’ symbol.
Bench Marks were first introduced during the first half of the 19th century as part of the official government surveying of Britain. Between 1831 and 1993 over 500,000 bench marks were created. In the current era of modern surveying techniques, using satellite based geographical positioning systems (GPS), the function of Bench Marks is now largely redundant and consequently they are no longer used or maintained.
Many of the churches surveyed by TTHG as part of the BitNE Project displayed OS Bench Marks. These were often to be found at knee height cut into one of the outer faces of the church bell towers. Two typical examples can be seen in Figure 11.
Figure 11: Examples of two OS Bench Marks recorded by TTHG as part of the BitNE Project. The one on the left being from Thorpe Thewles church whilst the one on the right is from Norton church
Miscellaneous & Other Latter Forms
Click on (+) For Information
In addition to the other forms of markings and graffiti discussed above there is a further category that clearly dates to the later 19th and 20th centuries. Unlike the well executed textual and memorial graffiti, described above, most of these later forms are of a much more crude appearance and created using pens, pencils, chalk, paint or sharp edged implements. They are most commonly found on wooden surfaces rather than inscribed into stone or plaster work. Such graffiti often takes the form of simple names and initials (often being dated) along with ‘doodlings’ of inanimate objects, animals, faces and people. Their often simple and ‘childish’ nature leads to the believe that the majority (but certainly not all) of them were the work of choirboys or children. This is further supported given the locations within churches in which such forms of graffiti are commonly found, e.g. on the surfaces of wooden pews found in the naves of churches and particularly in the choir stalls found in church naves. Further common places to find such graffiti are in vestries and within the enclosed areas often associated with organ chambers. These last two locations are the source of a wealth of such graffiti at Bishopton church (see Figure 12), this being one of the eight southeast County Durham churches surveyed by TTHG as part of the BitNE Project.
Figure 12: A selection of miscellaneous graffiti dating from the late-19th century to mid-20th century from within the vestry and the interconnecting eastern part of the organ chamber of Bishopton church
A list and basic interpretation of several additional forms of British church graffiti can be found online within the website of the Norfolk Medieval Graffiti Survey.
Survey Results & Reports
To review a summary of the results for each of the individual church graffiti surveys carried out by TTHG during 2023 select from the links below.
Copies of all of the official recording sheets and photographic images generated as part of this project were submitted by TTHG to the BitNE Project’s master archive, Tees Archaeology’s HER Officer and to each church’s resident vicar.
Although the BitNE Project formally closed in early 2024 the organisers encouraged its volunteers to carry on with their survey work and continue to submit their findings reports once complete. As part of this informal continuation of the project TTHG undertook additional graffiti surveys of the largely medieval fabric churches at Egglescliffe, near Stockton-on-Tees, and Stranton in Hartlepool. These surveys are on-going and will appear on this website once completed and submitted to the BitNE project organisers. TTHG plan addition church graffiti surveys in southeast County Durham in the coming years.
Recommend Background Information & Further Reading
If you are interested to learn more about historic church and non-secular building graffiti the following books and videos are highly recommended.
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.