
The origins of this project go back to 2010 when Thorpe Thewles History Group (TTHG) first became aware of a record of a now lost wayside cross, the “Thorpe Cross’ in Grindon parish. Interest in this subject led TTHG to undertake archival research into the history and original location of this once local landmark. In parallel to this the group launched a public appeal to ascertain if residents in and around Grindon parish knew of any surviving evidence (e.g. the whereabouts of any re-used sculptured stones built into local buildings in the area) or folklore concerning this now forgotten ancient monument. From previous research TTHG were well aware that examples of wayside crosses or cross fragments are known from all but two of the rural parishes running west from Aycliffe to the coast at Hartlepool. The only parishes in this chain without surviving evidence of such monuments were the adjacent ones of Redmarshall and Grindon.
In 2011 TTHG’s public appeals for information on this topic eventually led to a once in a lifetime discovery and one which experts at Durham University were later to declare as being of ‘national importance’. In the garden rockery of a former farmhouse were discovered three stone fragments of any early medieval cross shaft, part of what was later to be termed the ‘Carlton/Thorpe Cross’. Knowing the importance of this find, and the need for funding to properly record, investigate and publicise it, it was decided by TTHG to include its research as one of the principal elements of their next major local heritage project, entitled ‘Preserving our Yesterday’s for Tomorrow‘. This project was jointly funded by grants awarded by ‘The National Heritage Lottery Fund’ and ‘Point North’. The project ran from late 2024 to mid-2026. For this part of the overall project TTHG collaborated with experts from the Department of Archaeology at Durham University along with others from the national ‘Corpus of Anglo-Saxon Stone Sculpture’.
After being fully recorded, analysed and studied by the staff from the Department of Archaeology at Durham University, as part of the project, the ‘Carlton/Thorpe Cross’ was ultimately confirmed to be the lower part of a shaft from a Anglo-Scandinavian cross dating to the first half of the 10th-century. While it may never be known for certain if it once belonged to the ‘Thorpe Cross’, it is believed by TTHG to be a strong possibility.
For a summary of the project and its findings see the video presentation below.
As part of this project, and in order to better promote the discovery and history of the ‘Carlton/Thorpe Cross’, TTHG commissioned a photogrammetry based 3D model of the cross shaft by staff at Durham University (see below). The data from this model was subsequently used by Prototype Outline Services Ltd. (Middlesbrough) to 3D print a full-sized light weight replica of its conjoined remaining parts. This replica was subsequently displayed to the public at a project close out presentation held in Thorpe Thewles in March 2026. It is further planned to display the replica cross shaft at local libraries, museums and heritage events and to make it available to schools, colleges, universities and education groups across northeast England.
Copies of the projects findings have been made publicly available by both TTHG and Durham University via their various online information sharing and social media platforms with copies of final project reports, drawings and photographs etc. being also submitted to Tees Archaeology (TA) for inclusion in the region’s ‘Historic Environment Record (HER).
At the end of the project TTHG transferred the three remaining parts of the cross shaft to the care of TA. The monument is now stored in their regional archaeological finds storage facility in Hartlepool. Here they can be accessed by researchers and members of the public by prior appointment. Moving forward TTHG and TA have agreed to work together to find medium to long term placements for the monument within the region’s museums.
Project Sponsors, Collaborators, Supporters & Service Providers







For further information and the findings from the three separate phases of this extended project see the expandable information sections below. A comprehensive project findings and summary report can be found and downloaded from the in the second of these commentaries.
PROJECT PHASE I – The Search for and Discovery of a Lost Early Medieval Cross
In 2010, TTHG came across a passing reference in an old county history to a now lost wayside cross in the parish of Grindon, the ’Thorpe Cross’ (1). The county history cited its reference as two land charters (Egerton 512 and 514, see Figure 1) (2) which are now held in the British Library, London.

Egerton 512 and 514 are two similarly worded medieval land charters written in c.1199. They detail several parcels of land belonging to Matilda de Torp which were located in and around Thorpe Thewles. Translations of these documents mention a now lost cross that had obviously once been a well-known landmark in Thorpe’s landscape. In addition, the charters also mentioned a separate standing stone as also being in the vicinity of the village. This could be a reference to a further lost ancient monument in the area or may be a reference to a later removed free standing ‘glacial erratic’ of which a couple are known locally.
TTHG believed that the lost cross was likely to be a medieval stone wayside, boundary or preaching cross of which several are known to have once existed in the local area (see Figure 2). These include fragmentary examples from Hart, Billingham and Great Stainton, plus existing standing cross shafts and support sockets at Bishopton, Egglescliffe and Hartlepool. Many such crosses were purposely destroyed or buried during the Reformation period. Others are known to have simply toppled over during the passage of time, with their stone being later recovered and used for building purposes, sometimes at a considerable distance from where the cross had been originally erected.

To find out if anyone in the local area around Thorpe Thewles had ever heard of this lost ancient monument, and what may have happened to it, TTHG posted requests for information via its website and the local parish magazine. It was thought possible that parts of the lost cross could still exist incorporated into the wall of a local farmhouse, barn or built into the fabric of one of the many local stone bridges in the area.
After some considerable time a reply was received to one of the public requests from Maureen Pinkney a former resident of nearby Carlton. Maureen, then in her late 70s, was a respected local figure who had a vast knowledge of past events and people from the area. Amazingly, Maureen believed she knew of a sculptured stone which fitted the general description in TTHG’s appeal. It was in a rockery in what was once the front garden of Lilac House Farm in Carlton. Carlton is located just under two kilometres southeast of Thorpe Thewles and the two adjacent villages are connected by a direct road of at least medieval origin.
After contacting Philip Hardy, the owner of Lilac House Farm, to whom the front garden rockery belonged, TTHG arranged a visit to Carlton with Maureen to see if anything of interest could be found. The current buildings on the site of the former farmhouse, and the adjoining Sunnyside Cottage to the east (see Figure 3), are understood to date from the 1960s. They were built on the site of an earlier farmhouse of the same name whose history is documented back to the 18th century and almost certainly stretches back into medieval times.

On viewing the front garden of the former farmhouse there, half buried and projecting out of the rockery, was the rectangular stone block (see Figure 4) bearing surface relief decorations that are typically characteristic of those often found on early medieval stone crosses.

Having found and recovered one stone, it was decided by TTHG to return to the site a few weeks later to undertake a second and more extensive search across the gardens of the two adjoining homes. To TTHG’s great surprise two further pieces of sculptured stonework were discovered very close to where the first had been found.
With the kind permission of Philip, the recovered stones were donated to TTHG to secure their safe keeping and facilitate their further research. They were next relocated to Thorpe Thewles where they were washed, photographed, measured and preliminary drawings made of them. Once the stones had been cleaned and laid out alongside each other it was found that they fitted together to form a near complete 0.9 m long, and slightly tapering, shaft of what was undoubtedly part of an early medieval stone cross.
The surfaces of the lower part of the cross shaft are flat and cleanly dressed. These would have belonged to the hidden part at the bottom of the shaft that would have originally slotted in a separate support socket located at its base. The end of the upper part of the cross shaft displayed worn breakage surfaces indicating that the cross’ upper shaft and head must have been broken off in antiquity. One of the shaft’s side edges is worn smooth with none of its original sculptured designs left visible. The fractures between each of the three end sections of the shaft looked relatively ‘fresh’ indicating they were far more recent breaks. There also appeared to be one part of the cross shaft missing and where it should have fitted there was a distinct square stain of iron oxide, almost as if a steel or iron plate had once been fitted into the base of the broken-out section in the middle part of the cross shaft (see Figure 5).

Further communications with Philip enabled TTHG to put together a more recent history of the stones and their association with Lilac House Farm. Earlier in Philip’s life he remembers them being in the garden of the main farmhouse where they laid under a small tree on the property’s northwestern boundary. From here they must have been moved into the adjoining garden of Sunnyside Cottage where Philip’s parents had once lived. Here they ultimately found their way into the two adjacent rockeries, close to the property’s front pathway. Thereafter they had become forgotten about by all except the ‘eagle eyed’ Maureen Pinkney.
Further information supplied by Philip lead TTHG to Edith and Alan Chisholm of Carlton. They provided additional information about the stones prior to them being placed in the front garden of Lilac House Farm. According to Alan, the stones had originally been found by Fred Hall in the 1960s when he owned and still operated the farm. At the time Fred discovered them Alan believed they formed a single continuous block which lay in the floor of a former disused building which Fred was in the process of demolishing. This building had been a ‘gin gang’, housing the mechanism of a horse driven rotary mill. It is thought that the stone had formed the base support foundation for the mills central rotating vertical shaft. From memory Alan believed that Fred had said that the stone broke apart on lifting from the building’s paved floor. Gin gangs (see Figure 6) were commonly used on farms throughout Britain during the mid-19th to early-20th centuries. They were typically used to grind corn or animal fodder.

The earlier noted clean and more recently looking section breaks in the cross shaft, along with its one worn edge and the central recess (where an iron plate may once have been fitted) would all potentially fit with the story of the cross shaft having once been used as a basal support for a gin gang’s central rotating shaft.
Based on Alan’s information, TTHG next applied map regression techniques to try and ascertain approximately when Lilac House Farm’s gin gang had been built and confirm more accurately the date of its demolition. To aid in the dating task Philip showed TTHG what appeared to be a brick that had once formed part of the gin gang’s fabric (see Figure 7). On first appearances it presented as a typical handmade, red brick. However, on closer inspection one of its sides contained the stem and bowl section of an imbedded white clay smoking pipe.
This pipe possibly once belonged to the person who had originally made the brick or who had helped stack it in the kiln in which it was fired. It is likely that the pipe’s original owner temporarily placed it on a working surface prior to the wet clay brick being placed accidentally on top of it. The pipe then moulded itself into the base of the brick and, after being fired, became part of it. The diameter of the internal bores and stems of such clay pipes, along with their characteristic shape, size and decoration of their bowls, can be used to date them. In their day such pipes were cheap and short-lived working objects. By dating the pipe, TTHG would be able to better date the gin gang of which it ultimately became a part. Unfortunately, in this case the pipe was of a relatively generic type and design which had been popular during the 1860s to 1870s but which, in various slight variations, continued to be used through to the 1920s (Note 1).

TTHG’s Map regression results proved more conclusive in dating the gin gang. In the earliest known detailed map of Carlton (3), made in 1840, Lilac House Farm and its outbuildings are clearly visible. Their outline does not indicate the existence of a typical hexagonal or octagonal shaped plan of a gin gang. However, in a slightly later published map of the village from 1857 (4), the presence of such a structure on the outer side of the farm’s northern range of buildings is clearly visible. This same structure appears in all subsequent OS maps (see Figure 8) issued up until October 1965 but not in any surveyed after that date. The latter date for the gin gang’s demolition fits with the approximate period that Alan Chisholm had previously related to TTHG.
While TTHG now knew that the cross shaft had been built into the gin gang sometime between 1840 and 1856 (possibly closer to 1856 based on the dating of the clay pipe) they still didn’t know where it had originated from prior to that date. Had it been found in Carlton, or elsewhere in Redmarshall Parish, or could it have been found closer to Thorpe Thewles (or an alternative location) and then brought to the farm as a useful piece of building stone? Trying to prove that the cross shaft was part of the lost ‘Thorpe Cross’ was going to require more in-depth research.

Using the collection of mid-19th century tithe maps and apportionment documents, held by Durham University’s Special Collections Library (Palace Green, Durham), TTHG next undertook field name surveys for both Grindon and Redmarshall Parishes to see if there were any additional clues as to the former site of the lost ‘Thorpe Cross’ and possibly evidence of a further lost cross in the vicinity of Carlton, Redmarshall or Whitton.
TTHG reviews of both the field name evidence and published histories of Redmarshall Parish produced no evidence to indicate there had ever been a cross within the parish lands. That said, it still can’t be ruled out that one may once have existed as both written and field name survey evidence is never fully conclusive.
TTHG’s preliminary field name survey of Grindon parish (Note 2) was cross referenced, where possible, with the several medieval field names given in the Egerton Charters of c.1199. Despite being able to confidently identify at least three field names mentioned in the charters, which had survived (with varying degrees of alteration) into the mid-19thcentury, TTHG wasn’t able to pinpoint the former location of Thorpe Cross. All that could be determined was that it likely stood in a broad area defined northeast of Thorpe Thewles village, west of the former site of Blakeston Hall and north of Middlefield Farm (see Figure 9). This is an area of land whose surface topography has changed considerably since the late-19th to mid-20th centuries due to the extensive extraction of near surface sand and gravel deposits.

While it may never be known for certain if the remaining parts of the ‘Carlton/Thorpe Cross’ once belonged to the ‘Thorpe Cross’, it is believed by TTHG to be a strong possibility.
Notes:
- TTHG would like to thank Heather Coleman (Member of The Society for Clay Pipe Research) for her preliminary dating of this clay pipe.
- TTHG has been recently made aware of three additional sources which potentially include reference to 17th to 19th century field names covering the southern part of Grindon parish and the adjoining northwestern part of Norton parish. The future study of these will allow TTHG to continue its search for field name evidence which may further help pinpoint the former location of the ‘Thorpe Cross’. The findings from any future research work will be presented by TTHG if they prove to generate positive results.
Sources:
- Page, W. – A History of the County of Durham. Volume III. Victoria County History, London, 1928.
- Egerton Cartularies 512 & 514 – British Library.
- DDR/EA/TTH/1/38 – Carlton Township (Redmarshall Parish) – Tithe Map, 1840. Durham University Special Collections Library. Palace Green, Durham.
- Ordnance Survey Map – Durham Sheet L (6 inches to the mile). Surveyed 1857, Published 1859.
PROJECT PHASE II – The Recording, Investigation & Publication of the ‘Carlton/Thorpe Cross’
By 2024 TTHG had taken its research of the Carlton/Thorpe cross as far as it could alone. To move forward help would be needed from a team of multi-disciplined experts. This would come at a cost. It was at this point that the group decided to incorporate any further research in the cross as part of its then proposed project, ‘Preserving our Yesterdays for Tomorrow‘. During the year-long grant preparation and bidding process for this project TTHG approached staff in the Department of Archaeology at Durham University (DU) to ascertain if the two organisations could work together in the next phase of the cross’s recording and investigation. After receiving copies of TTHG’s photographs of the re-conjoined cross shaft fragments, staff at the university and the national ‘Corpus of Anglo-Saxon Stone Sculpture’ (CASSS) project declared them to be a find of ‘national importance’ and that the project was one they would like to work on. Subsequently, TTHG prepared a scope of work for DU to undertake as part of the proposed project. The latter was shared with Tees Archaeology, who had already been made aware of TTHG’s find and who kindly agreed to support their grant applications. The principal components of DU’s scope of work were to address the following:
- Report on the style, form, and dating of the cross to which the stones belonged and to fully record the find in CASSS’s national data base.
- Prepare a set of drawings, images and a research report to fully record the cross it in the CASSS’s national data base.
- Undertake chemical and mineralogical analysis of the stone from which the cross was made and propose a regional location from where it was quarried.
- Undertake analytical investigations to determine if any residual pigment remains could be found on the stones’ sculptured surfaces.
- Undertake photogrammetry and 3D scannings of the stones in order to generate an online interactive model of the three conjoined cross fragments. The data derived from this exercise was also to be presented in a form that allow others to create a life size light weight replica of the cross shaft as a separate exercise.
- Conduct a review of the content of the ‘Egerton Charters’ and undertake independent historical document reviews and field name studies to try and better confirm the location of the ‘Thorpe Cross’ and to ascertain if any documentary or field name evidence exists to support the possible existence of another lost wayside cross in the adjacent parish of Redmarshall (i.e. that in which Carlton is located).

Research Findings & Conclusions
The following represents a high-level summary of the findings and conclusions from this phase of the project. For a more detailed analysis and comprehensive description of the cross and its sculptured designs and motifs reference should be made to the embedded report below which represents its official entry in the CASSS.
Summary Findings
Experts at Durham University (DU) confirmed the cross to be early medieval in origin. Based on the very distinctive designs and motifs incorporated into its sculptured surfaces, its cultural origins have been determnined to be Anglo-Scandinavian. It displays several design features which are characteristics of several 10th century Hiberno-Norse crosses known from the Isle of Mann, Cumbria, North Yorkshire and County Durham.
Based on stylistic and decorative comparisons with other crosses from this period, particularly those from the local Northallerton/Sockburn/Brompton group along with others at Stanwick, Hawkser, Gilling West, Gainford, Aycliffe and Crathorne, the Carlton/Thorpe cross is believed to date from the first half of the 10th century. For a detailed discussion of the motifs and designs on the cross shaft’s surfaces reference should be made to pages 2 to 5 of the above embedded report. It should be noted that these designs and motifs represent both pagan Scandinavian and Anglo-Saxon christian influences and symbology.
Analysis and comparison of the remaining parts of the Carlton/Thorpe cross to others in the CASSS data base, have led Durham University to conclude that it forms the bottom part of a much longer shaft which would have been topped with a head possibly similar to that of the ‘Brompton Cross’. The overall height of the original cross has been estimated as 1.81 m. This excludes any additional gain in height from its basal support socket. The cross shaft’s lower 16 to 17 cm (i.e. that comprising plain dressed surfaces) would have originally slotted into a ground based socket or possibly one built into the top of a stepped platform. For further details see Figures 15a-c in the above embedded CASSS Report.
The project’s investigations to determine the presence of residual micro-pigment samples, from across the surfaces of the cross shaft, proved negative. It is now generally held that most early medieval crosses were originally painted. The lack of any surviving pigment samples on the Carlton/Thorpe cross is almost certainly due to a history of long term exposure to the elements.
Mineralogical examinations of stone fragments taken from the Carlton/Thorpe cross proved interesting. Based on the surface texture and red colouring of the Carlton/Thorpe stones it had originally been assumed that the cross was quarried from a locally sourced sandstone. This proved not to be the case. The stone was in fact discoloured (probably due to weathering and contact with iron rich soils) magnesium limestone sourced from the ‘Cadeby Formation’. This formation outcrops across a narrow strip of land extending from North Yorkshire to Nottinghamshire (see Figure 16 of the above embedded CASSS Report). Interestingly there are only three other 10th century crosses known north of the River Tees that have been cut from simliar stone. The bulk of the others are located close the the Viking administrative centre of York. This area is thus a high contender from where the cross’ stone was sourced.
DU’s independent reviews of surviving historical documents (which included field names gathered from a range of estate and tithe map documents) backed up TTHG’s early findings and conclusions. Based on topographical and some remaining field name evidence a general area could be agreed for the location of the ‘Thorpe Cross’ as briefly outlined in the Egerton Charters 512 and 514. However, no conclusive evidence could be found to link the cross shaft pieces found at Carlton with the above historically mentioned monument which was once a well known feature in the land scape around Thorpe Thewles c.1199. Given this lack of definitive evidencethe project has conculded that it is safest (at least for now) to refer to the monument as the ‘Carlton/Thorpe Cross’. The migration of fallen crosses, or cross parts, for re-use as building material is known at several locations across the country. In such examples stone from the crosses has been be transported 2 to 3 km from the cross’ original documented locations. While this observation might support the possibility of the Carlton/Thorpe stones having once formed part of the ‘Thorpe Cross’ it could equally be argued that they could have belonged to a cross unrecorded in history that once stood at nearby say Redmarshall where a church with a pre-Norman foundation is suspected.
For its official listing in the CASSS convention dictates that the cross discovered by TTHG takes the name of the location at which they were found, i.e. in this case the ‘Carlton Cross’.
Summary Conclusions
Despite there being no evidence for Carlton/Thorpe cross’ original geographical setting, it may be concluded that it was most likely a church/cemetery marker although its use as an estate or boundary maker can’t be ruled out. If it was commissioned as a burial ground marker it was likely associated to a settlement and estate belonging to a member of the Hiberno-Norse elite within the context of their political takeover of the region. The individual who commissioned and raised this stone may well have had strong connections to the region’s new Hiberno-Norse authorities based at York, and indeed even to one of their leaders, possibly the self proclaimed King Ragnall/Ragnald. Such associations would have facilitated the sourcing, carving and shipment of the cross from ancient known quarries at Tadcaster or ‘robbed’ from early decayed Roman sites at, or near, York. The transport of the cross from either of these locations to Thorpe Thewles or Carlton would have represented a considerable effort and expense. Such a visible act of patronage and affiliation may well have taken place in the context of the gift of land by Ragnall/Ragnald to one or a group of his followers north of the RiverTees. The Carlton/Thorpe cross, carved with ribbon-like beasts, was a Christian monument, but also a statement of new Hiberno-Norse aspirant lordship and strong affiliation to York, and like its comparands, used motifs and imagery that looked back to pre-Scandinavian designs while also integrating Hiberno-Norse influenced forms and imagery.
PROJECT PHASE III – The Creation of a Replica of the Carlton/Thorpe Cross Shaft & Its Subsequent Educational Use & Public Display
As part of DU’s recording of the Carlton/Thorpe cross each of the remaining stones belonging to the cross’ lower shaft was recorded using conventional photography and drawing methods. Additionally, the were imaged using photogrammetry and subjected to imaging and surveying techniques using a very high accuracy 3D scanner, in this case a hand held Artec Leo device. The output data from the latter imaging methods was subsequently used to creat an interactive virtual 3D model of the cross’ remaining conjoined stones which can be freely accessed worldwide by anyone who has internet access (see link to 3D model above). This model provides not only an excellent record of the cross shaft but an invaluable teaching aid.
ABOVE: Images of Alexander Jansen(Durham University) scanning one of the Carlton/Thorpe Stones using the ‘Artec Leo’
As a separate part of the project, the highly accurate survey data generated from DU’s 3D scanning of the stones, was used as the basis to create a portable, life size model of the cross shaft complete with its now missing reverse face section. This model was commissioned by TTHG from the Middlesbrough based company, Outline Prototype Services (OPS). This highly specialist company offers a wide range of 3D printing and associated prototype part and industrial model making services. TTHG worked closely with OPS throught the project and visited their offices on a number of occasions to monitor progress in the replica cross’ development and agree on final design details such as surface texture and colour finishing details. The replica is made of four sections that slot together and fit onto a motorised turntable.
ABOVE: Various images of the 3D printing, project meetings and final replica cross shaft on display
This replica is now being used for display purposes at local history and archeological events as well as forming a fantastic new addition to TTHG’s general educational outreach activities with local school children and adult educational groups. It is also intended to use the replica as an insirational focal object for use with local art and creative writing groups.
ABOVE: The replica of the Carlton/Thorpe cross shaft being used by TTHG as a teaching aid at West Park Primary School (Hartlepool) and displayed at UNESCO’s World Heritage Day in Durham Castle

















































































































































